| Song | Artist | Recommended by |
| 1 | Beginner | AKB48 | HoshinoSakura |
| 2 | Spirit in the Sky | Norman Greenbaum | MrHubris |
| 3 | Joy to the Land | Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach | drunkenpanda |
| 4 | If You're Feeling Sinister | Belle and Sebastian | happyclapper |
| 5 | I'm in the Battlefield for my Lord | Rev. D.C. Rice and his Sanctified Choir | Thesubhuman |
| 6 | Telephone to Glory | The Ho'opi'i Brothers | BeltwayBandit |
| 7 | Dropkick Me Jesus | Bobby Bare | misterbadexample |
| 8 | Hymn | African Head Charge | Shoegazer |
| 9 | Assibavi | Orchestre Poly-Rhythmo de Cotonou | nilpferd |
| 10 | We Need a Whole Lot More of Jesus and a Lot Less Rock 'n' Roll | The Waney Family | thewinslowboy |
| 11 | A Santa Barbara/Que Viva Chango | Celina y Reutilió | alexito |
| 12 | Comfort Eagle | Cake | NoxiousGumbo |
| 13 | Let the Mystery Be | Iris Dement | jrowen81 |
| 14 | Cargo Culte | Serge Gainsbourg | bemilu |
| 15 | From a Distance | Bette Midler | thoughtballoons |
| 16 | I Believe | Frankie Laine | attwilightlarks |
| 17 | Zu Zu Mamou | Dr. John | Thesubhuman |
